advertisement



TV Dinners -- Watch What You Eat Print E-mail
by Charles Stuart Platkin   
Sunday, 09 July 2006
I had my first TV dinner in 33 years last night -- in fact, I sampled 10 of them. Although they have improved in terms of quality, the more dramatic and important development is in variety -- specifically the low-calorie, low-fat options.

The TV dinner got its start about 50 years ago when C.A. Swanson & Sons had too many frozen turkeys -- 10 refrigerated railroad cars full, to be exact. They needed to come up with an innovative way to make use of them -- and behold, the TV dinner was born. Today, frozen entrees account for more than $5.9 billion in annual supermarket sales.

For years, the TV dinner market meant obscene amounts of fat and calories to ensure tasty and exciting food for those of us who just didn't have the time to prepare meals from scratch. Now with all the low-calorie options such as Lean Cuisine, Smart Ones, and Healthy Choice, we can enjoy the convenience of frozen meals and still be able to lose or maintain our weight. "Additionally, these healthier meals are a great resource for dieters who have difficulty keeping their portion sizes under control," says New York City Nutritionist Shira Isenberg, R.D.

But don't run to the supermarket yet. The meals that bill themselves as "healthy," "lean," or "smart" vary widely in nutritional content and -- a key point -- size. Some boast very low calorie and fat contents, but have small portion sizes. So, you really have to consider whether or not one portion will satisfy you. Truth be told, when I put those 10 frozen meals on my dining room table, the one that stood out as a "real" meal was the only one that was not low in fat or calories -- the mammoth Hungry Man Backyard BBQ XXL. In fact, this "1 1/2 pound" dinner packs a whopping 1140 calories, 127 grams of carbs, and 46 grams of fat.

"We are a society of supersizers -- if someone is used to eating large portions of food for dinner, and he or she is trying to lose weight, it's unlikely that a low-calorie TV dinner will be satisfying," explains Dr. Teresa Moore, an exercise physiologist and nutrition expert at the University of South Carolina's School of Public Health. "And when someone's not satisfied, he or she tends to eat additional foods that can be high in calories and fat."

Most of the low-calorie options that I tested (including Smart Ones, Lean Cuisine, and Healthy Choice) were just okay in terms of taste -- there were no particular standouts in the crowd. I guess my taste buds are in line with the Consumer Reports "tasters." A few years ago they made the same call, claiming that "most of the products tried were mediocre at best." They went on to say that "the best-tasting products, sorry to say, had the most fat and sodium -- substances that generally enhance flavor, even though high fat and sodium didn't guarantee a high [flavor] ratings score."

That said, with the hundreds of choices available, there are certainly enough healthy, low-calorie meals to try, and some are bound to meet your culinary desires -- I even found a couple that I liked enough to eat again (like the Lean Cuisine Asian Style). But be wary and watch out for the following:

LOOK FOR THE WORD "HEALTHY." By federal law, any foods that say "healthy" (including the brand "Healthy Choice") on the packaging must meet certain government standards; they must contain less than 3 grams of fat per 100 grams and no more than 30% of calories from fat. In addition, sodium content cannot exceed 600 mg.

WATCH THE SODIUM. "If the meals are low in calories and fat, then how can they be tasty at all? In some cases, the answer may be sodium," says Dr. Lisa Ritchie, a dietitian and assistant professor of family and consumer sciences at Harding University. Many frozen dinners do have high sodium content, so aim for no more than 700 mg per serving as a guide.

WATCH THE FAT. Your meal should also contain no more than 3 grams of total fat and no more than 1 gram of saturated fat per 100 grams of food -- this usually means keeping the fat to a total of 6 to 8 grams per meal or entree. Also, watch out for trans fatty acids -- many of the low-calorie, low-fat products contain these types of fats. You can spot them on the food label if you see the words "partially hydrogenated" on the ingredients list.

ADD FRUITS AND VEGETABLES. It's difficult to find a frozen dinner that includes enough fruits and vegetables -- so add your own. Peel an orange, slice up an apple, get some frozen string beans or broccoli -- not only will this increase your nutrient consumption, but you'll also feel more satisfied.

GET MILK (OR YOGURT). TV dinners are often low in calcium, so make up for it by adding a cup of skim milk or yogurt to boost your calcium consumption.

HAVE A SOUP OR SALAD. Add low-calorie soups and salads (watch the dressing) to fill you up so you don't end up feeling hungry -- especially if you're used to having "supersized" meals.

The Good:

Smart Ones Fajita Chicken Supreme
280 calories
33 g carbohydrate
7 g fat

Smart Ones Pepper Steak
240 calories
32 g carbohydrate
5 g fat

Tyson Italian Style Chicken Meal
310 calories
38 g carbohydrate
4 g fat

Healthy Choice Chicken Breast and Vegetables
230 calories
29 g carbohydrate
5 g fat

Healthy Choice Oriental Style Chicken
240 calories
28 g carbohydrate
5 g fat

Lean Cuisine Chicken with Almonds
280 calories
44 g carbohydrate
4.5 g fat

Ultra Slim-Fast Creole Shrimp Entree
240 calories
45 g carbohydrate
4 g fat

The Bad:

Stouffer's Ham and Asparagus Entree
520 calories
32 g carbohydrate
36 g fat

Buitoni Meat Lasagna Single Serving Entree
580 calories
57 g carbohydrate
19 g fat

Stouffer's Cheese Tortellini in Alfredo Sauce
580 calories
35 g carbohydrate
37 g fat

Old El Paso Cheese Enchilada Entree - Festive Dinner
590 calories
51 g carbohydrate
31 g fat

Banquet Sweet and Sour Chicken Entree, Extra Helping
650 calories
64 g carbohydrate
34 g fat

The Ugly:

Banquet Turkey Entree, Extra Helping
750 calories
68 g carbohydrate
42 g fat

Hungry Man Fried Chicken Entree (mostly white meat)
800 calories
79 g carbohydrate
39 g fat

Marie Callender's Penne Pasta and Pepperoni Entree
800 calories
74 g carbohydrate
43 g fat

Banquet Salisbury Steak Entree, Extra Helping
910 calories
49 g carbohydrate
60 g fat

Marie Callender's Chunky Tuna and Noodle Entree
960 calories
43 g carbohydrate
35 g fat


CHARLES STUART PLATKIN JD MPH is a nutrition and public health advocate, author of the best seller Breaking the Pattern (Plume, 2005), Breaking the FAT Pattern (Plume, 2006) and Lighten Up (Penguin USA/Razorbill, 2006) and founder of Integrated Wellness Solutions. Copyright 2006 by Charles Stuart Platkin. Sign up for the free The Diet Detective newsletter at www.dietdetective.com
Bookmark:
Delicious
Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
YahooMyWeb
Technorati
Digg
blogmarks
Stumble
Blinkbits
Trackback(0)
Comments (1)Add Comment
...
written by Princess April, April 02, 2008
I eat tv dinners once in a while I mostly help cook meals with my Parents at my apartment. I watch what i eat and I avoid eating too much sweets at home and at work.

Write comment

busy
Last Updated ( Sunday, 09 July 2006 )
 
< Prev   Next >


home   |   about   |   privacy   |   advertising inquiries and policy   |   terms and conditions   |   contact   |   in the news   |   media/pr contacts

Contact the Diet Detective by email at info [at] DietDetective.com  if you have any questions or comments about the site or column.

The mission of Diet Detective is to make sure you have and understand the information you need to live a healthy lifestyle.