advertisement



Avoiding the Shanghai Surprise Print E-mail
by Charles Stuart Platkin   
Wednesday, 12 July 2006
I grew up eating Chinese food at least once a week -- my favorite dish was General Tso's chicken. That changed about 9 years ago when the Center for Science in the Public Interest did a study on Chinese food and found out just how unhealthy it really is. This study was especially important because an earlier survey showed that the average consumer thought Chinese food was "more healthful" than the typical American fare.

The Chinese diet, long known for its emphasis on grains, vegetables, fruits, and legumes, has fueled the perception that Chinese food is healthy. Unfortunately for our waistlines, we have significantly altered this healthy diet, with the end result being what we currently see on the menu at our local Chinese restaurant.

So how can you still enjoy Chinese food without packing on the pounds? Here are a few pointers to help you navigate the menu:

AVOID THE FRIED: I know this sounds obvious, but the point is that you can enjoy Chinese food without going for fried foods. If you do anything, avoid "deep fried" completely. Deep-fried dishes like Sweet and Sour Chicken, Sesame Chicken, and my favorite, General Tso, can pack over 1000 calories and about 70 grams of fat! While you're at it, be wary of stir-fried dishes, too. Trust me, they're not using a tablespoon of oil like you do at home. Aside from the oil, these dishes are usually fairly nutritious.

SPEAK UP: Most Chinese food is made to order, so ask for your food steamed. If you can't bring yourself to take it that far, ask the server to have the dish prepared with little or no oil. If you're clear and insistent, you can get them to keep out much of the oil. You can also request that chicken or fish be used in place of red meat in your favorite dishes, and for extra green veggies as a side. Avoid meals that are described as breaded or contain eggs or nuts, or at least ask to have these high calorie items left out.

KEEP IT BROWN AND STEAMED:
If it's available, choose brown rice instead of white rice for extra fiber, and order steamed rice -- not fried rice. Aside from the obvious, fried rice also contains a lot of egg, which adds more calories, fat, and cholesterol. Choosing steamed rice trims 13 to 20 fat grams (about 3 to 4 teaspoons of oil). But just because it's brown doesn't mean you can go to town -- it still has calories. The steamed stuff packs about 217 calories per cup, so watch those portion sizes!

WATCH THE SAUCE: Don't just dump the main dish onto the rice. Use a fork to get the veggies and meat on top of it, leaving the pool of fatty sauce behind. Try not to "drink" the sauce that comes with your dish -- this is the primary source of fat in most instances. By using chopsticks or a fork, you can leave more of the calorie-laden sauce on the serving plate and not in your belly. Or even better, how about ordering the dish steamed with garlic and herbs, and have the sauce on the side? This way you can dole it out consciously. In a cup and a half, a typical brown sauce has about 255 calories, 7.5 g fat, and 41 g carbohydrate, whereas a black bean sauce contains as much as 358 calories, 30 g fat, and 14 g carbohydrate for a cup and a half serving.

EXTRA VEGGIES: Order a few sides of vegetables steamed in garlic and herbs. You can mix them with your main dish -- a welcome addition to any stir-fried food. And because the veggies increase the portion size, the entree will serve more people while also cutting back on overall calories. 

CUT THE CRISPIES: Watch out for those crispy things they put on the table. Whether it's colorful shrimp toast or crunchy Chinese noodles, they've all been fried. Just a single cup of chow mein noodles has 237 calories with nearly 14 g fat and 26 g carbohydrate -- and you can probably eat significantly more than 1 cup waiting for your main dish to arrive. Three pieces of shrimp toast contain 222 calories and a whopping 14 g fat, plus 16 g carbohydrate, and that's before the actual entree! Also, watch where you dip those noodles. Saucy Susan Duck Sauce has 80 calories, 0 g fat, and 19 g carbohydrate for just 2 tablespoons. 

DON'T GO NUTS: While many nuts have health benefits, they are very high in fat and calories. Since most Chinese dishes are already fattening, it's a good idea to stay away from these menu items. At the very least, ask the kitchen to go light on the nuts -- even just a few nuts can go a long way in enhancing taste and flavor. Ten peanuts have about 51 calories, 4 g fat, and 2 g carbohydrate. Ten cashews (which are bigger than peanuts) have about 91 calories, 8 g fat, and 4.5 g carbohydrate.

ADD SOUP: Soup can be a great way to fill up as long as you choose carefully. Plus, the serving sizes tend to be small, so you are less likely to overdo it. Start out your meal with a bowl of hot and sour soup. One cup contains only 160 calories, 8 g fat, and 5 g carbohydrate -- wonton soup is slightly higher at 182 calories, 7 g fat, and 14 g carbohydrate per cup. And despite its name, egg drop soup (without noodles) is the best deal with only 70 calories, 3 g fat, and 3 g carbohydrate per cup.

PORTION DISTORTION: Most Chinese restaurants in America are independently owned, and therefore portions vary from place to place. Keep in mind that many dishes are meant to be shared with at least one other person. A typical order of Chinese food can be more than 4 cups!

SODIUM: Chinese food tends to be very high in sodium. Stay away from anything made with soy sauce; even the reduced-sodium soy sauce contains over 500 mg of sodium per tablespoon. Skip the soup too, since it's rare to find a low-sodium soup at a Chinese place.

WATCH THE FRUIT: This means anything orange- or lemon-flavored. Their fruity names might imply a nutritious choice, but in fact, these types of dishes usually involve deep-fried meats covered in a citrus-flavored sauce, which may also contain oil.

THE GOOD (based on 2 cup serving unless otherwise noted)

Fortune cookie (one cookie): 30 calories, 0 g fat, 7 g carbohydrate
Steamed vegetable or seafood dumplings (one dumpling): 41 calories, 1 g fat, 4 g carbohydrate
Steamed brown rice (1 cup): 217 calories, 1.8 g fat, 45 g carbohydrate (contains 3.5 g fiber, compared to white rice's 0.6 g fiber)
Meatless Lo Mein: 270 calories, 1.5 g fat, 54 g carbohydrate
Steamed chicken and broccoli (no sauce): 280 calories, 12 g fat, 13 g carbohydrate
Steamed Tofu and Veggies: 293 calories, 12 g fat, 28 g carbohydrate

THE BAD (based on 2 cup serving unless otherwise noted)

Crab Cake (1 cake): 107 calories, 5 g fat, 0.5 g carbohydrate
White rice, steamed (1 cup): 205 calories, 0.4 g fat, 44.5 g carbohydrate
Szechwan Shrimp: 350 calories, 21 g fat, 26 g carbohydrate
Stir-fry Veggies and Tofu: 473 calories, 32 g fat, 28 g carbohydrate
Meatless Chop Suey: 497 calories, 14 g fat, 80 g carbohydrate
Chicken Chow Mein: 548 calories, 27 g fat, 40 g carbohydrate

THE UGLY (based on 2 cup serving unless otherwise noted)

Egg Roll* (one roll): 190 Calories, 11 g fat
Spare Ribs (5 Ribs): 805 calories, 58 g fat, 11 g carbohydrate
Sweet and Sour Pork: 950 calories, 50 g fat, 92 g carbohydrate
General Tso's Chicken: 1173 calories, 68 g fat, 65 g carbohydrate
Sesame Chicken: 1318 calories, 74 g fat, 68 g carbohydrate
Pork Fried Rice: 1483 calories, 56 g fat, 186 g carbohydrate
Orange Crispy Beef*: 1496 calories, 65 g fat

*Carbohydrate content not available.


CHARLES STUART PLATKIN JD MPH is a nutrition and public health advocate, author of the best seller Breaking the Pattern (Plume, 2005), Breaking the FAT Pattern (Plume, 2006) and Lighten Up (Penguin USA/Razorbill, 2006) and founder of Integrated Wellness Solutions. Copyright 2006 by Charles Stuart Platkin. Sign up for the free The Diet Detective newsletter at www.dietdetective.com
Bookmark:
Delicious
Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
YahooMyWeb
Technorati
Digg
blogmarks
Stumble
Blinkbits
Trackback(0)
Comments (2)Add Comment
2 more cents
written by jacky, November 14, 2008
Mr Platkin and Mr "Article" are both correct. While Chinese food normally eaten by Chinese is quite healthy and nutritious, Chinese restaurant food even in China can be calorie and fat intensive. This is because they are often special occasion dishes, and not usually eaten daily. Also the style of Chinese cuisine is a significant factor in the ingredients and method of preparation, ie using more oil to stir fry versus using more water to steam/braise.

But the biggest factor is that Chinese restaurants, being market driven, will compile their menus to what customers want to order; especially for "Chinese-American" restaurants, this has evolved into the stereotypical dishes like, fried rice, sweet-sour pork, General Tsao's chicken, etc.

So, Chinese food can be very healthy or very unhealthy. Just don't order those fried or oily dishes; there ARE other things on the menu...
...
written by Absurd Article, October 12, 2007
First off, General Tso (Zuo) Chicken is not Chinese. Neither are egg rolls, sweet and sour pork, sesame chicken or the other stuff you listed. Second, since you get your "Chinese" food in restaurants, it's highly unlikely that you've ever eaten Chinese food. For the past 2 months, I've been eating one or two Chinese meals EVERY day. In that time, I've lost about 15 pounds, so it's quite obvious that Chinese food is not fattenening. This article is indicative of someone who is culturally clueless.

Write comment

busy
Last Updated ( Thursday, 13 July 2006 )
 
< Prev   Next >


home   |   about   |   privacy   |   advertising inquiries and policy   |   terms and conditions   |   contact   |   in the news   |   media/pr contacts

Contact the Diet Detective by email at info [at] DietDetective.com  if you have any questions or comments about the site or column.

The mission of Diet Detective is to make sure you have and understand the information you need to live a healthy lifestyle.